Donald Coxe and his colleagues at BMO Harris provided their post-election views following the Obama victory:
Donald Coxe, Global Portfolio Strategist, BMO Financial Group
- Obama’s victory will lead to a “feel-good” attitude within America at a time when gloom and sourness have become excessive. That favours financial assets generally at a time that fall is moving into winter.
- Obama’s spending plans will be seen as economy-favourable with the nation in recession. Stocks should benefit near-term.
- Obama is fully committed to continuation of all the ethanol subsidies and tariffs that McCain opposed. That is good news for the reeling ethanol stocks that have been buffeted by falling oil prices and still-high corn prices.
- Obama has threatened to impose carbon taxes on coal-fired electrical generating plants.
- None of the candidates promised significant revisions to the extremely favourable royalty structure for mining on federally-owned properties, mostly in the West. That is important for Canadian gold miners operating in Nevada.
- He famously said that on his first day in the White House he would “call up the President of Canada to announce he was tearing up NAFTA.” We believe he won’t do that.
- Worldwide, the election of a new U.S. President with a change agenda will be greeted favourably. This should facilitate America’s dealings with other nations on such hot topics as Russian expansionism and response to Iranian nuclear weapons development.
Andrew Busch, BMO Capital Markets, Global FX Market Strategist
- Expect a U.S. stimulus package of $150 billion to be enacted and checks out the door by March with an impact on consumer spending by late April and May.
- Expect very expensive bond deals issuance to be done over the next three months with those issuing likely to only be high quality to get done and with high spreads to Treasuries. This should mean they get snapped up.
- There is going to be massive government bond issuance in 2009 across the globe to pay for bailouts, stimulus packages, and social spending. This means we should see a further steepening of the yield curve in 2009, but it won’t necessarily point to a big economic recovery like it has in the past.
Jack Ablin, Chief Investment Officer, Harris Private Bank
- Both an Obama victory and a Democrat-controlled Congress are currently factored into markets.
- When looking at Europe vs. U.S. price-to-sales comparisons, one can see the U.S. is beginning to trade like a “nationalized” country.
- Tax rates are expected to increase which will give an edge to municipal bonds.
- A move towards socialized medicine appears to be already discounted. In examining the valuation of U.S. vs. European pharmaceutical stocks, the U.S. valuation already incorporates nationalized health care.
- Large cap is set to outperform as small cap moves back to normal valuation.
Paul Taylor, Chief Investment Officer, BMO Harris Private Banking
- We are a long way away from a sustainable equity market rally. A sustainable equity market rally will only occur when it is clear that the spectre of a protracted, significant U.S. economic recession is not in sight.
- Leading economic indicators signal a meaningful U.S. and global economic recession. This will cause policymakers in Washington to focus attention on the economy as the number one priority.
- Investors should have a defensive strategy, with an overweight in Consumer Staples, Telecom, Utilities and underweight in Energy, Materials and Technology. This will be more appropriate until the spectre of recession is past.
- With Fed Funds at 1.0%, monetary policy will be impotent moving forward.
- A global economic recession is bearish for commodity based currencies (Canadian and Australian dollars) and is bullish for other currencies. The current “crisis of confidence” is bullish for the U.S. dollar due to its position of reserve currency.
Source: PR Newswire
Tags: Australia, BMO, BMO Capital Markets, Canada, Currency, Dollar, Donald Coxe, Economy, energy, Euro, Fed, Focus, Gold, Markets, Mining, Monetary Policy, Oil Prices, Recession, REW, Russia, spreads
Posted in Markets | No Comments »
A snapshot view of commodities reveals that they have all experienced some mild recovery at the end of the month of October, as liqudation pressure caused by the deleveraging of hedge fund and bank balance sheets which wreaked havoc on markets during the month subsided. Its been little more than a week since TARP began deploying funds in a meaningful way. Also, another factor seems to have been the destabilization that was caused by the covering of short positions in Dollar/Yen carry trades that forced further liquidation in equity and commodity markets making October 2008 the worst month in 21 years. These conditions have been profoundly deflationary.
The following chart shows how as a result of high commodity prices the daily cost of living rose incrementally to a high of an additional cost per capita of $4.77. While the turmoil in commodity market has been terrible for investors, the turn has been beneficial to comsumers, who are now enjoying a $2.58 dividend off the resultant cheaper cost of living.
In the above chart we calculated the ‘08 price change of the major food and energy commodities in the CRB index (Corn, Soy, Wheat, Cattle, Hogs, Oil and Natural Gas) and multiplied the changes by the annual per capita consumption of each item. While this method may oversimplify the actual costs, it provides a good idea of how changes in commodity prices have impacted consumers wallets this year. (Bespoke)
Volatility in commodities is sure to continue and their prices have still a long way to go before the upper limit of the current downtrend line is broken. Under present circumstances, if you consider the economic growth numbers for the US economy continue to show up in the negative GDP growth and the credit market volatility continues to reign on the markets’ parade, commodity prices could face more downward pressure.
Charts: Bespoke Investment Group
Tags: Banks, Carry Trade, Chart, Commodities, Credit, Credit Market, Economy, energy, GDP Growth, Gold, Markets, Natural Gas, Silver
Posted in Markets | No Comments »
Click image for video
Ken Heebner, CGM Funds, and Frank Holmes, US Global Investors, discuss emerging markets in the context of the Fed’s 50 bps rate cut last week. Both their remarks on the rate cut and emerging markets are noteworthy.
Ken Heebner, CGM Funds: “Well, the emerging market economies are going to continue to have long-term growth. Those are the markets down the most, they’re down 50, in some places 60 percent and long term they have a bright future. Even Jeremy Grantham, the mega… the bear, is saying they’re almost cheap enough for him to buy. … When he’s ready to buy something, it’s going to go up.”
Frank Holmes, US Global Investors: “Well, I do like the emerging markets and I think if you look at energy names like PetroChina, it’s been just devastated here in stock price and it has a huge upside to get back to basically a healthier equilibrium and P/E ratios. But remember that most of these emerging markets, unlike 10 years ago Erin, they have, like China has $2 trillion of U.S. dollars…so they have a huge (foreign reserve) surpluses to be able to reinvigorate their economies. …I totally agree with Ken, this is where growth opportunities lie.”
Tags: China, Dollar, Emerging Markets, energy, Fed, Frank Holmes, Markets, Silver, Video
Posted in Markets | No Comments »
Thomas J. Barrack Jr., billionaire and Founder of Colony Capital, which controls $39-billion in real estate assets, in his recent newsletter, “Is the world going to an [Extinction Level Event?” provides his assessment of the state of the markets, and shares the following:
Why the Banks Have Most Likely Not Hit Bottom
• Corporate earnings from most sectors will be weak and capex programs will be slashed.
• Hedge funds will continue to be tortured by redemptions and their interplay with banks was
incestuous.
• The effect of hedge funds pulling out of the market will chill many sources of corporate
finance - Redemptions are massive.
• Counterparty risk in the CDS market will remain a bit of a mystery.
> CDS was equally as bad at the plate as equity and debt players
> The governments infusion of equity collapsed the CDS spreads
• CDS payments and failures at levels that are unfathomable - watch Lehman reconciliations on
Tuesday, Oct. 21st.
• The housing market will remain anemic.
• Insurance companies, automakers, airlines and shippers are all in trouble.
• State and municipalities are also Fed borrowers.
• Corporate refinancings at $150 billion a quarter with no one to refinance.
• Massive margin calls on the titans of America which will cause collapse in the corporate
equities they own.
• Forced liquidations.
• LBO restructurings and covenant violations.
• No DIP financing for bankruptcies, only liquidations.Long-term Consequences
The good news is that all we care about at the moment is SURVIVAL. We need to fight every day to monitor and steward the best deals we can find — the ones we own. However, eventually we will need to examine the long-term effects of our triage.
• Huge inflationary pressures. Inevitable higher interest rates and taxes.
• Massive national debt and budget deficits.
• Are we deferring the pain like Japan did?
• $11.3 trillion national debt is really $55 trillion due to OBL (off balance-sheet liabilities).
• Implications of investment losses for pension funds and endowments?Bottom Line
The game is afoot and not over. Don’t panic and don’t be euphoric. The discoveries will be constant and unsettling. Fortunately, the world powers have committed to win it. Now we all have to figure out what exactly that means. Based upon our past experience at implementing bank takeovers and “distressed asset” management and dispositions, we suggest that we all buckle our seatbelts for a longer ride with lots of ups and downs before we arrive to safety.
From Bloomberg, October 10, 2008:
“For once, it will be better to be late rather than early,” Barrack said in a four-page letter to investors on Oct. 8, a copy of which was obtained by Bloomberg News. “There is no bottom because no one believes the messenger.’
“As all markets come to the realization that we are now in a worldwide systemic recession — not just a credit crunch — things may get worse,” the Los Angeles-based Barrack, 61, wrote in the letter, titled “In God We Trust — But Not Counterparties.”
“The massive restructurings, refinancings and re-pricings that will now take place, cascading from the financial world to the industrial world, will be legend. The complexities, repercussions and consequences to all parties are indeterminate.”
From Donald Trump’s Blog, the Donald quotes his good friend’s (Thomas Barrack Jr.) newsletter:
Why Can’t Anybody Find the Bottom?
It all boils down to trust! The mantra of the country is “In God We Trust–but not counterparties.” No buyer trusts any seller, banker, insurer or intermediary. No investor trusts any depository, insurer, broker-dealer or advisor. No Main Street citizen trusts Wall Street, and neither Main Street or Wall Street trusts the government. No counterparty in any transaction has confidence in the other. Values at every level have been artificially adjusted and when the air comes out of the “speculative hope certificates” everyone is pointing fingers at each other for fault and retribution.
The Worst is in Front of Us
Counterparties are renegotiating, borrowers are violating covenants, banks are finding any excuse not to fund existing commitments, insurers are negating liability, and renegotiations of responsibility and liability are being conducted at every level of the capital structure across the spectrum of companies.
There is no bottom because no one believes the messenger. With trillions of dollars of re-pricing occurring in these markets there is no hurry to catch the falling knife. There will be ample time once that last “dead cat bounce” has bounced and the government launches a coherent and consistent program. For once it will be better to be late rather than early.
Bottom Line: This is Not the Bottom.
Thomas J. Barrack Jr., “Is the World Going To ELE?”, October 14, 2008
Source: NakedShorts.com, Colony Capital
Tags: Banks, CDS, Credit, Dollar, energy, Fed, Housing Market, inflation, interest rates, Japan, Markets, Real Estate, Recession, spreads, Value
Posted in Economy, Markets | No Comments »
Judging by the way that commodities prices have literally been “drawn and quartered” since July, its obvious that the market has been forced into liquidation by the massive unwinding or rather de-levering caused by the near failure in the credit market, and the assumption of debt by governments and central banks around the world.
Gold, notably, has traded lower during this anomalous selling-spree, even though it has long been regarded to be the real asset choice of those wanting to protect against financial risk. Perhaps its simply either that gold is highly liquid at a time of great need and is being sold off, or there has been a substantial amount of central bank intervention by way of shorting gold in the futures market. Either way, given the sheer amount of money supply growth, by contrast, gold is very cheap. Which brings us to platinum. Take a look at these charts:
Platinum, which is 30X rarer than gold closed at $793, only $83 premium to the price of gold. At peak earlier this year, platinum traded at a $1,300 premium to gold.
Oil is continuing to get cheaper. OPEC held an emergency meeting, agreeing to cut production by 1.5 -million barrels. News of this had no effect on oil prices, not even an intermediate effect; it closed on Friday at $64.15. Which begs the question: Is OPEC really a cartel? They seemed content to sit back and watch gleefully as the price shot up to 147, but have been unable to do anything to stop its slide to current levels, not even a substantial cut in production. Or so it seems.
Is the imminent food crisis over? Are fears of oil shortages overwrought?
Right now, it looks like nobody cares. They just want their money out, and at any price.
As Warren Buffett has put it so eloquently in his recent NYTimes Op-Ed piece, Buy American. I am, “Be fearful when others are greedy, and be greedy when others are fearful. And most certainly, fear is now widespread, gripping even seasoned investors.”
Charts: Bespoke Investment Group
Tags: Banks, Chart, Commodities, Credit, Credit Market, Dollar, EFU, energy, Gold, Oil Prices, Platinum, Silver
Posted in Agriculture, China, Commodities, Credit Markets, Crude Oil, Economy, Emerging Markets, Gold, Markets, Oil & Gas, energy, inflation | No Comments »
Hugh Hendry, CIO, Eclectica Asset Management told Power Lunch Europe that it will take 10-20 years to heal from the current turmoil in markets. This is a must see interview.
click image for video
Here is the summary of the interview:
Hendry has avoided risk the last few years. His hedge fund is up 20% YTD and 42% this month. He has been investing more heavily in long term US treasuries recently. Hendry is looking at increasing the risk exposure in his hedge-fund’s portfolio.
He pointed to Mervyn King’s hinting toward the “R” word as putting it mildly, that the big “D” is in the forecast.
“It’s not a question of losing out in a recession, I’m talking about 10 or 20 years before we recover from this. This is a catastrophe,” Hendry told “Power Lunch Europe.”
Hendry made an example of Hungary. He lambasted the Hungarian central bank governor, Mr. Andra Simor, who described the situation as akin to “the slower antelopes in a chase being devoured by lions one after the other.”
This stems from Hendry’s past involvement in discussions with European financial officials about European convergence.
Hendry specifically alludes to discussions he’d had with the Hungarian governor in particular regarding the integration of Hungary into the EU and that he warned against the way in which they planned to finance their move with Swiss Francs and Yen via the carry trade.
While in violin-playing posture, Hendry claimed,”It’s tragic.”
“What it [the reel] doesn’t reveal is that I sat there, he just said, you’re rubbish. I’m Hungary. I’m going join the EU. My interest rates are 8% and they’re going to be 4%. You’re a fool, You can’t catch me Mr. Lion, I can outsmart you, I can outrun you. And I said “I dare you.”
I said, “I’ll give you a head start.”
They suspended all economic rationality. Mortgages were given to poor people in Swiss Francs and Japanese Yen. They took on an enormous foreign exchange risk, because they thought that the little antelope could outrun the lions of economic intelligence. And you can’t.
Hendry said, “You can game the system, but you can’t beat it.”
There’s nothing crude, there’s nothing moral here. They were wrong.”
Dominoes. Iceland, Hungary, Latvia, Bulgaria, Eastern Europe, the dominoes are crashing. There’s economic disequilibrium. The economic chaos which we ignored for 5 years because we were bribed to ignore it, because they paid high interest rates. It was a bribe to ignore reality. But in a world where everything is falling down, the dominoes just crash. There is no answer.
Hendry’s beef is with EU and UK regulators and officials.
“I’m the heretic. I was laughed at, scoffed at, dismissed, ignored, at a time when investment bankers who advise governments, and who manage money, took reckless risk upon reckless risk.
We reached a point at which the Royal Bank of Scotland had a bigger balance sheet than the economy. Everyone looked the other way. Its not a question of losing out in a recession. I’m talking about 10 or 20 years before we recover from this. This is a catastrophe.
Forget about Mervyn King, UK Finance Minister, saying the “R” word. You wait until he says the “D” word.; depression. We had interest rates in the UK at 5% for a year as everything collapsed.
There’s a notion of stall speed. Never allow an aircraft to reach stall speed. That is the pledge central bankers must make. ” We won’t allow the economy to reach stall speed,” because everything below that you’re pushing on a string.
Interest rates in the UK will be 2% at the end of next year, and they’ll be 2% at the end of the year after that.
The ECB, the most hideous, intellectually conceited group of bankers, raised interest rates this summer; history will send the ECB to damnation because they have sent us to damnation. That’s the reality.
Thank you Mr. Hendry.
Tags: Carry Trade, COT, ECB, Economy, energy, Euro, Fed, Hugh Hendry, interest rates, Japan, Markets, Mortgage, Recession, SMI, UK, Video
Posted in Markets | No Comments »
Andrew Lahde, the hedge fund manager, who last year, was catapulted into the limelight when he successfully returned 886% to investors, betting against subprime mortgages, closed up shop last month, claiming that counterparty problems were making it far too difficult and stressful for him to want to keep on going.
Below is Lahde’s farewell and f— you letter to those who deserve it.
Dear Investor:
Today I write not to gloat. Given the pain that nearly everyone is experiencing, that would be entirely inappropriate. Nor am I writing to make further predictions, as most of my forecasts in previous letters have unfolded or are in the process of unfolding. Instead, I am writing to say goodbye.
Recently, on the front page of Section C of the Wall Street Journal, a hedge fund manager who was also closing up shop (a $300 million fund), was quoted as saying, “What I have learned about the hedge fund business is that I hate it.” I could not agree more with that statement. I was in this game for the money. The low hanging fruit, i.e. idiots whose parents paid for prep school, Yale, and then the Harvard MBA, was there for the taking. These people who were (often) truly not worthy of the education they received (or supposedly received) rose to the top of companies such as AIG, Bear Stearns and Lehman Brothers and all levels of our government. All of this behavior supporting the Aristocracy, only ended up making it easier for me to find people stupid enough to take the other side of my trades. God bless America.
There are far too many people for me to sincerely thank for my success. However, I do not want to sound like a Hollywood actor accepting an award. The money was reward enough. Furthermore, the endless list those deserving thanks know who they are.
I will no longer manage money for other people or institutions. I have enough of my own wealth to manage. Some people, who think they have arrived at a reasonable estimate of my net worth, might be surprised that I would call it quits with such a small war chest. That is fine; I am content with my rewards. Moreover, I will let others try to amass nine, ten or eleven figure net worths. Meanwhile, their lives suck. Appointments back to back, booked solid for the next three months, they look forward to their two week vacation in January during which they will likely be glued to their Blackberries or other such devices. What is the point? They will all be forgotten in fifty years anyway. Steve Balmer, Steven Cohen, and Larry Ellison will all be forgotten. I do not understand the legacy thing. Nearly everyone will be forgotten. Give up on leaving your mark. Throw the Blackberry away and enjoy life.
So this is it. With all due respect, I am dropping out. Please do not expect any type of reply to emails or voicemails within normal time frames or at all. Andy Springer and his company will be handling the dissolution of the fund. And don’t worry about my employees, they were always employed by Mr. Springer’s company and only one (who has been well-rewarded) will lose his job.
I have no interest in any deals in which anyone would like me to participate. I truly do not have a strong opinion about any market right now, other than to say that things will continue to get worse for some time, probably years. I am content sitting on the sidelines and waiting. After all, sitting and waiting is how we made money from the subprime debacle. I now have time to repair my health, which was destroyed by the stress I layered onto myself over the past two years, as well as my entire life — where I had to compete for spaces in universities and graduate schools, jobs and assets under management — with those who had all the advantages (rich parents) that I did not. May meritocracy be part of a new form of government, which needs to be established.
On the issue of the U.S. Government, I would like to make a modest proposal. First, I point out the obvious flaws, whereby legislation was repeatedly brought forth to Congress over the past eight years, which would have reigned in the predatory lending practices of now mostly defunct institutions. These institutions regularly filled the coffers of both parties in return for voting down all of this legislation designed to protect the common citizen. This is an outrage, yet no one seems to know or care about it. Since Thomas Jefferson and Adam Smith passed, I would argue that there has been a dearth of worthy philosophers in this country, at least ones focused on improving government. Capitalism worked for two hundred years, but times change, and systems become corrupt. George Soros, a man of staggering wealth, has stated that he would like to be remembered as a philosopher. My suggestion is that this great man start and sponsor a forum for great minds to come together to create a new system of government that truly represents the common man’s interest, while at the same time creating rewards great enough to attract the best and brightest minds to serve in government roles without having to rely on corruption to further their interests or lifestyles. This forum could be similar to the one used to create the operating system, Linux, which competes with Microsoft’s near monopoly. I believe there is an answer, but for now the system is clearly broken.
Lastly, while I still have an audience, I would like to bring attention to an alternative food and energy source. You won’t see it included in BP’s, “Feel good. We are working on sustainable solutions,” television commercials, nor is it mentioned in ADM’s similar commercials. But hemp has been used for at least 5,000 years for cloth and food, as well as just about everything that is produced from petroleum products. Hemp is not marijuana and vice versa. Hemp is the male plant and it grows like a weed, hence the slang term. The original American flag was made of hemp fiber and our Constitution was printed on paper made of hemp. It was used as recently as World War II by the U.S. Government, and then promptly made illegal after the war was won. At a time when rhetoric is flying about becoming more self-sufficient in terms of energy, why is it illegal to grow this plant in this country? Ah, the female. The evil female plant — marijuana. It gets you high, it makes you laugh, it does not produce a hangover. Unlike alcohol, it does not result in bar fights or wife beating. So, why is this innocuous plant illegal? Is it a gateway drug? No, that would be alcohol, which is so heavily advertised in this country. My only conclusion as to why it is illegal, is that Corporate America, which owns Congress, would rather sell you Paxil, Zoloft, Xanax and other additive drugs, than allow you to grow a plant in your home without some of the profits going into their coffers. This policy is ludicrous. It has surely contributed to our dependency on foreign energy sources. Our policies have other countries literally laughing at our stupidity, most notably Canada, as well as several European nations (both Eastern and Western). You would not know this by paying attention to U.S. media sources though, as they tend not to elaborate on who is laughing at the United States this week. Please people, let’s stop the rhetoric and start thinking about how we can truly become self-sufficient.
With that I say good-bye and good luck.
All the best,
Andrew Lahde
Tags: Bear Stearns, Canada, capitalism, energy, Euro, Focus, FT.com, Mortgage
Posted in Markets | No Comments »
Donald Coxe, Chief Investment Strategist, BMO Capital Markets, has published his latest issue (October 8) of Basic Points, titled “Homeicide: The Crime of the Century.” Given the release date of this issue, its interesting to see how timely his calls to action are.
Particularly, we would highlight Coxe’s call to reduce general equity exposure further, prior to what was one of the worst weeks ever (last week), and to not wait too long to buy agricultural stocks.
Columbus Day 2008 will go down in the history books as the single-biggest one day rally since 1933, the Dow rising 936 pts (its biggest one day point closing ever, and fifth largest %-age closing) . This rally followed the US government’s announcement that it would take an equity stake in the banking sector, by injecting $250-billion into the sector.
Its still early though, and as Coxe says, this is likely a “Mama Bear.” Question is, is this a Mini-Mama Bear (like late1980’s or late 1990’s) or a Big Mama (like 1930’s). In the full text of Basic Points, a must read, Mr. Coxe explains himself fully.
Here, we summarize his recommendations:
Thank you Mr. Coxe.
The complete report is available here.
Tags: Basic Points, BMO, BMO Capital Markets, Credit, Credit Market, DOG, Dollar, Donald Coxe, Economy, energy, Gold, inflation, interest rates, Markets, Metals, Mining, Mortgage, precious metals, Recession, Value
Posted in Markets | No Comments »
From Jim Cramer in New York magazine:
What will New York look like a year from now? The answer: bad and probably worse, and perhaps downright catastrophic. Three degrees of awful. The first step was passing the bank-bailout legislation. Now that it’s done—and if it didn’t get done we would have been looking at a guaranteed economic collapse—the critical issue will be presidential leadership. And while any president will be an improvement over the current one, there is a growing belief on Wall Street that Barack Obama has the capacity to lead us out of this wilderness while John McCain does not. I’ll go a step further: Obama is a recession. McCain is a depression…
At this time next year, I could see the Dow as low as 8,300. That’s more than 40 percent off its October 2007 high of 14,164. On Main Street, that means a further slowdown in consumer spending, as buyers feel poorer, and another hit for 401(k) and college savings accounts. For Wall Street, it means more bank closures and mergers and still more layoffs. The two remaining independent commercial banks–née–investment banks, Goldman Sachs (GS) and Morgan Stanley (MS), will have to fight mightily to remain independent. The bet here is that Goldman makes it but Morgan Stanley succumbs to one of the four emerging megabanks — Citigroup (C), JPMorgan (JPM), Bank of America (BAC), and Wells Fargo (WFC)…
In terms of investing between now and next fall, I’d buy the stocks of only companies you can’t not use—Kellogg’s (K), General Mills (GIS), Kraft (KFT), P&G (PG). You can’t trust anything to do with financial paper — there’s still too much uncertainty (if a bailout bill does pass, at what price will the toxic bonds be marked?). And commodities have been bid up too high — demand soared as investors sought shelter from stocks — to buy for some time. Oil’s going to $50 on weaker demand; when it gets there, we can revisit the oil stocks.
Tags: Banks, Citigroup, Commodities, energy, Gold, oil stocks, Recession
Posted in Markets | No Comments »
Ongoing credit market turmoil and a rapidly deteriorating economic outlook have hit global equities very hard.
Ongoing credit crunch worries and evidence of resultant effects on the global economy are diminishing the remnants of confidence among investors. Investors are fleeing all risk assets indiscriminately, moving into safe havens such as cash and government securities. Widening concerns of global bank failures continue (regardless of last week’s approval of the U.S. TARP program, now anti-climactic), bringing about runs on banks in several countries and preventing financial institutions from lending to one another.
Germany and Denmark announced guarantees on all private deposits following Ireland’s first-mover decision last week. Looks like we’ll have to wait for Europe to come to some unified solution such as a concerted bailout, and some nationalization of the banking sector in some of the larger markets.
Source: BCA Research, October 7, 2008
Tags: Banks, Credit, Credit Crisis, Credit Market, Economy, energy, Euro, Germany, Markets
Posted in Markets | No Comments »
Niels Jensen and Jan Wilhelmsen of Absolute Return Partners (www.arpllp.com) produced an informative analysis of the credit crisis and provide the following observations. Here is our summary:
Loans and Mortgages are getting much harder to come by on average, globally.
This has bold and negative implications for property prices everywhere.
Observation # 1
It all began with housing and it will end with housing.
The current overhang caused by the tightness of credit (mortgages) will take years not months to unwind and housing prices will not begin to rise again until this occurs.
Observation# 2
Don’t trust central banks to always do the right thing.
Evidence suggests that while their intent seems to be genuine, central banks around the world have not been very effective at taming inflation. For example, simply raising interest rates in the underlevered economies of the BRIC countries has been futile, since most consumers and companies do not employ credit to the extent that those of us in the west do.
In the case of the BRIC countries, it appears the problem does not consist of sustaining growth, but rather containing growth. China, for instance, has a record of under-reporting both real and nominal GDP growth, and may have only recently more accurately stated inflation owing to the fact that they could not hide from skyrocketing oil and food prices.
Observation # 3
Policy mistakes are likely to be repeated.
The US is currently at risk of making the same policy making mistakes Japan made 10-15 years ago. US residential property prices have risen more during 2000-2006 boom than did the Japanese during the late 80s boom.
Japan too, though more rapidly, reduced the cost of money dramatically to fend off its crisis.
Japan bailed out many of its institutions and used taxpayers money to fund the activity of fixing the ‘unfixable,’ and this could have profound implications for the US GDP growth in years to come.
Observation # 4
The golden era of investment banks is over.
The biggest independent investment banks have just become banks. The US investment banking business is becoming more like Canada’s where the business is dominated by the large schedule “A” chartered banks and America’s “free” market just became a little more socialist. How ironic…The folding of GS and MS into banks also has valuation considerations for the venerated firms as their revenues and earnings are sure to decline under the auspices of Fed regulation. Further de-levering also has negative implications for the market as it entails more liquidation. Hopefully this will be done in an orderly fashion now that the conversion is underway.
Observation # 5
The final shoe hasn’t dropped yet.
There is more to come. For instance, the financial system has yet to deal with $1-trillion in Alt-A securities and further degradation of the CDS market and counter-party risks.
Absolute Return Partners states that the commodity bull is just the final leg of the liquidity super-cycle: take a look the Economist’s VAR-VAR-Voom chart.
Observation # 6
Leverage is ‘dead’ but capital is not.
Global savings rates now exceed 20%, except in the US, and while this is a positive for global stability, the question remains about whether investors are willing to invest money where it is most needed, the shore up the world’s banks. Failing that, property prices will need to stabilize before we can expect better times.
Observation # 7
The end of the crisis looks further away than it did a year ago.
Its complicated, very complicated.
Commodity price induced inflation has made it hard for policy makers to reduce interest rates. Despite this, interest rate cuts may not be the magic bullet and in 20 of the 36 countries recently surveyed by Morgan Stanley, real short-term interest rates are currently negative.
At this point the $700-billion Treasury/Fed proposal appears to be a solid response, as does the stimulus injections of cash into markets around the world.
This problem remains possibly years away from being done with.
Observation # 8
Traditional risk management has lost its way.
Paul McCulley of Pimco touched on the subject in the July 2008 issue of Global Central Bank Focus:
“[...] every levered financial institution - banks and shadow banks alike - decided individually that it was time to delever their balance sheets. At the individual level, that made perfect sense. At the collective level, however, it has given us the paradox of deleveraging: when we all try to do it at the same time, we actually do less of it, because we collectively create deflation in the assets from which leverage is being removed.”
In fact, while it is known that PIMCO was regularly consulted by Secretary Paulson, it was Paul McCulley who rightly proposed in his newsletter during the summer, that the only real solution would consist of the formation of a new government agency to create a market to thaw frozen or cemented assets. This would be the only viable long term solution.
Conclusion
Where is the opportunity? According to Absolute Return Partners, real value is to be found in credit instruments. This is where the most damage has been inflicted and it is where the biggest bargains are to be found in today’s markets.
What would you rather own? Equities which trade at 15-20 times earnings or credit instruments trading at a fraction of that cost? Deutsche Bank estimates that senior secured loans are trading at an implied PE ratio of 5-less than a third of the cost of equities.
You may read the full original version, at Observations on a Crisis, Courtesy John Mauldin
Tags: Banks, BRICs, Canada, CDS, Chart, China, Credit, Credit Crisis, EFU, energy, Fed, Focus, Food prices, GDP Growth, Gold, inflation, interest rates, Japan, liquidity, Markets, Mortgage, Paul McCulley, Paulson, PIMCO, Savings Rate, Trading, Value
Posted in Markets, inflation | 1 Comment »
Today’s trading in the oil saw the front month October contract, which rolled over today, close at $123, opening up a 12% spread between itself and the 2nd month November contract. During the course of the day it traded up as high as $130. When traders smells a short squeeze, they tend to pile in.
Word is that a large investor got caught on the wrong side of the trade and moved to cover a large short position.
The CFTC is said to be investigating the cause of today’s anomalous trading.
AP reported, “Phil Flynn, analyst and oil trader with Alaron Trading Corp. in Chicago, said the late-session surge in oil appeared to be the result of a large investment fund scrambling to cover their short positions, or bets that prices would fall.
“When people sense that someone is short, it’s like blood on the streets. It just accelerates the rally,” Mr. Flynn said.
The November contract closed at $109.37 also up sharply by about $6.62. If the price of oil manages to maintain above the $108-109 level, it may break the current downward trendline established since oil began its correction from the July $147/bbl peak .
It remains to be seen if energy prices will be impacted by a recession-led fall in demand. At last glance this evening, the November contract was trading just below 109.
Charts: Bespoke Investment Group
Tags: Chart, energy, Miscellaneous, Recession, Short squeeze, Trading
Posted in Markets | No Comments »
The following chart shows how the ten sectors of the S&P 500 performed this week in the context of the government’s credit market intervention. Only energy (on oil’s price recovery) and financials (on bailout) made progress while eveything else was down.
It was a crazy week in stocks too. Merrill Lynch (MER) was the best performer on news that it was being acquired by Bank of America (BAC) and AIG was the worst performing stock on news that it would receive a two-year $85-billon loan from taxpayers.
Charts: Bespoke Investment Group
Tags: Chart, Credit, Credit Market, energy, Financials, Miscellaneous, S&P 500
Posted in Markets, inflation | No Comments »
Oil prices rallied back over $100 in the midst of this weeks turmoil, to close Friday at $104, up $6. According to the current downtrend, oil, which appears to be in a bull market consolidation, is likely to continue lower for the time being, unless it can break the trendline and close above $108-$109.
Chart: Bespoke Investment Group
Tags: Chart, energy, Oil Prices
Posted in Markets | 1 Comment »
September 17, 2008 - The fall in the price of oil during the past two months may not have surprised everyone, but its dramatic nature and swiftness was unexpected. One analyst who got it right was Rob Fraim of Mid-Atlantic Securities. With crude down by almost 40%, a new report on energy has just been published by Rob.
This report is worth perusing for two reasons: (1) Rob has a good long-term track record in this sphere, and (2) a common-sense approach and findings with which I mostly concur. Here are some excerpts from his current report.
Today I will tackle one of the (many) issues with which market participants are grappling. And I will have a sector recommendation that has “hero or a goat” implications for the writer of this missive.
I am cogitating on the disruptions and disasters in the financial sector – and the implications for the broad market. At some point you will hear from me on that subject as this mess unfolds and I feel that I have actionable thoughts to share.
Today though – we talk energy.
I’ll probably get tons of e-mail taking exception to my conclusions and citing multitudinous arcane bits of Economist World data. And I will gladly receive these and will appreciate the input. But that doesn’t have to mean that I will necessarily agree or find reason to change my conclusions.
I am approaching this … and I don’t want to use the word “gut feeling” – given that I believe that I have sound reasons for my opinion on this – but there is a certain amount of “feeling” involved in the process and conclusions. What I see in market action, what I hear from clients, what I sense in the mood of market participants, what I observe in the market’s reaction to events. And with all due respect to economists, the market is often more art than science. So I don my proverbial beret, pick up my figurative brushes and paint, and present my art project. Some fact, some feel, lots of opinion.
What a bleak mood in the energy patch. What a sickening slide. What the h*** happened? What an … opportunity?
Back on June 10, in a piece I wrote entitled “Oil – Whither Goest Thou? ”I gave the opinion that crude oil – then at $136 a barrel was overextended and due for a correction. I said that the $100 or so area looked about right. Of course oil promptly rallied to $147 or whatever it was and I was a stoopie-head for a little while. But since then, well … hey, hey what a genius, huh?
You don’t believe that I actually got something right? OK, you force me to quote/copy/paste. Here is an excerpt from the June 10 flash in which I recommended lightening up on energy stocks:
“Do I think that oil is going to $50? Not a chance? Not $50, not $60, not $80. But I do think that there is a better than average chance that we are going to revisit $100-ish and stabilize there for a while.
“This being the case I am suggesting that reaping some profits and reducing energy positions a bit might be a wise move – at least on a trading basis. Keep a core holding for the long-term, but lighten up. Sell some stuff. Write some covered calls. Hedge a bit. Maintain the core but trade with part of your energy investments. Do something other than get whipsawed.
“… It would not surprise me to see $100-105 oil by the end of the year. That probably equates to gasoline in the $3.50-ish area.”
Of course after that I went on to elaborate brilliantly (oh all right it wasn’t that brilliant, but I did elaborate) on the reasons why I was – at that time, in June – becoming cautious on energy. Recapping (sans the details) the reasons for the selling recommendation were:
a) Demand destruction resulting from changing consumer and transportation industry driving habits and vehicle choices
b) The potential for a rise in the US dollar
c) Slowing demand for China with the Olympics build-out winding down
d) Modest production growth – specifically from Russia
e) Comments from the Saudis saying that there was no justification for the rise in oil prices that had occurred.
Hmm … not too shabby on those points if I do say so myself.
And then I stated the following:
“When the crowd is virtually all leaning in one direction on a sector, you have to take advantage of it at some point. You just have to. Right now everybody says that financials are garbage and energy is gold, and we of course know all of the reasons for both. But just you wait and see… 12 months, 18 months out – when quality banks have risen 30% in price – the analysts will fall in love with them again. And if energy stocks go down 20% the cries to sell will erupt. We have to take the opposite side of the masses sometimes. We. Just. Have. To.”
So as it turns out I was reasonably on target with those comments and the call to reduce energy holdings for a while. (You know what they say about even a blind squirrel finding an acorn every now and then.) Now the burning question on the minds of my readers is this: “What now, Rob?” Well, again, I don’t know how many minds are burning and hearts yearning to hear the answer, but I’ll take a crack anyway.
I don’t expect a huge rally in oil in the near term, but I do believe the correction has just about run its course. Recently when crude approached $100 on the way down, OPEC began the “defending” process by announcing some production cutbacks – hoping to maintain $100 as floor of sorts. But now with the disruptions across all segments of the market, oil prices have moved right through that level – particularly yesterday as panic hit all markets, trading below $92 as I write this. I would not be surprised to see OPEC coming back with more production curtailments.
I am somewhat more bullish on natural gas prices than many analysts I have read, more based on seasonality, but also because of increased focus on natural gas use. (We’ve all seen the Boone Pickens/Aubrey McClendon ads. And we are approaching an election – what politician is going to badmouth natural gas? Heck, Nancy Pelosi said that it isn’t even a fossil fuel. As to the seasonality play, I have had some success through the years in buying natural gas stocks in the fall prior to our entering the heating season for a trade out as spring approaches.
So, I’m kind of reasonably positive on oil itself – the commodity – for the short term. I’m growing more bullish on natural gas – against the opinion of some smart people who feel otherwise.
The key point though is that I am getting significantly more interested in the stocks of the energy companies. Why? Because it doesn’t take $140 oil for the energy companies to make a lot of money. They do very nicely at $100 and the resultant decline in gasoline prices (once we get past this hurricane pricing anomaly) will calm down some of the finger-pointing and windfall profit-espousing by the politicians.
And the prices of the energy company stocks – oil and gas producers, drillers, coal companies, energy trusts, MLPs, alternative energy … the whole bunch of them – have just absolutely plummeted over the last couple of months and it (